I like the commenting idea - because it is a REAL PAIN when 3 or 4 of us are talking in one thread and not everyone knows that a reply was made, and having to go through all of the comments to follow the conversation is just >.<
One thing I was wondering about is a comment purge every so often - not on the photo comments, on the comments left on a user's profile page. I have 3 years' worth of comments on my profile page, and the only way I can get rid of them is to "hide" them. OH!!!! That's another thing - being able to edit your own comments!!!! I *hate* that we can't do that on dA. Even if there is like a 15 minute limit on the edit - just SOMETHING.
As I already told Wayne, it's far too early for press releases and announcements. I'd rather that this plan be kept to ourselves for now, other than those from the "outside" whose input I've specifically asked for. I already have two non-KN people who are willing to be beta-testers, and one is on dial-up, which is why I asked her.
The ajax full-view is pretty, but if it's going to cause problems in the flow of usability, I can live without it. I do not, however, want fullviews going on a separate page upon click, with no options whatsoever on that page. Users will not like it if they can't fave, comment, order, whatever from fullview. I agree, the comment box MUST go directly under the image, on both midsize view and fullview. I hate having to scroll to the bottom of the page, especially if I am writing an installment on the adventures of The Feared Pirate Dog Bud. It's a pain to have to keep scrolling up to look at the photo I'm writing from.
I like the flyout or dropdown menu for the dashboard.
Shoutboxes/Shoutboards. At the very least, some type of Shoutboard is a must, because alot of us use them for features and stamps.
For example: [url=\"http://adaera.deviantart.com/journal/\"]http://adaera.deviantart.com/journal/[/url]
For those who are not familiar with the features on a dA image page:
[url=\"http://www.deviantart.com/deviation/59178188/\"]http://www.deviantart.com/deviation/59178188/[/url]
Note the Embed and Thumb codes at the bottom right of the image information. The thumb codes are what are used for making features like in my journal and shoutboard. The Embed feature can be turned off by the artists. As can the ability to download the photo, send it to mobile, the option to make it a print or not - the print thing is going to be important in regards to what we do in the way of a store.
[url=\"http://help.deviantart.com/\"]http://help.deviantart.com/[/url] < how they do their FAQ's - which for the most part can be totally useless. Take note that a limited amount of html coding is permitted in journals and comments/replies.
Oh and by the way, Orby needs a sprucing up. They can have "Fella" but we have ORBY!!!

/blum.gif\' class=\'bbc_emoticon\' alt=\':P\' />
More viewing space is a good thing for subscribers. We need ads, but let's not get carried away.
Oh and emoticons: UNIFORM AND CLEAN not like these: [url=\"http://comments.deviantart.com/emoticons\"]http://comments.deviantart.com/emoticons[/url]
Okay, that is all for now, seeing as I am making Wayne stay awake to read my reply to their longass conversation

/bigwink.gif\' class=\'bbc_emoticon\' alt=\';)\' />